I've been re-reading the Dragons from the CD-ROM compilation and ran across this letter and response in issue #3 (October 1976 - published over 27 years ago). In light of the current issues with MP3s, software piracy, etc., I thought it was rather interesting:
"Dear Sirs,
A couple of weeks ago I wrote to you asking for permission to xerox some of your tables. I had taken them and cut them out, laid them out differently to provide a compact set of all important tables for GMs. I wanted to sell them to a few friends at cost (no profit). I received a short, curt reply, stating: “Dear Sir: In response to your question, no, you may not reprint anything.
...[skipped]...
I therefore find it hard to swallow or understand your attitude. Not only would I not be competing with an extant TSR product, I would not even be seeking or making a profit. I would only be trying to make the like of people who already bought all your products
easier. And, although I’m not a lawyer, I have some doubts of the legality of your preventing photocopying of your material in a different form for non-profit purposes. I believe Congress has, or is in the process of, modifying the copyright laws to take into account the “Xerox revolution.” I would not try to sell my tables over your objections on such grounds, however, since — despite my dissatisfaction with this stance — I still have great respect for your company.
Everyone is grateful to TSR for providing us with such a useful, flexible, and fascinating fantasy game. But, for God’s sake, youíre not providing effective products for enthusiasts of your game; it seems you are doing a disservice to your loyal customers by preventing others from providing these products as long as they’re not trying to make a profit."
The response:
"Sorry to distress you, Scott, but the NO still stands, and will do so until we have a few matters resolved. Right now, we have denied permission to everyone not licensed by us because it was the only way to sort out just what is going on.
I agree that fandom is a good thing, and would do nothing to stifle it, but we had to draw a line, and now are faced with sorting out the mess. At such time that we have accomplished this, then we will be able to give permission where appropriate. At this time our policy is NO EXCEPTIONS, draconian as that may seem.
I don’t know where you got your information regarding copyright law, but you have it just backwards; if we (publishers and printers) have our way, the new laws you speak of will clamp down on the “rip-off revolution, ” as it should be properly known.
..."
I'm not advocating piracy of any kind (though I don't support the methods the RIAA, MPAA, and others are following, either). I just thought it was an interesting parallel to the present day.
(Yes, I realize that there are bigger issues today - the potential for mass distribution is far higher with the Internet, electronic goods can be duplicated exactly as opposed to how photocopies generally turned out, etc.)
Labels: RPG